It was just past midnight on February 4, 1880, when the quiet rural community of Biddulph Township, Ontario, erupted into chaos. The peaceful night air was torn apart by the roar of flames licking the sky, the acrid scent of smoke mixing with something far darker—vengeance. In a brutal and horrifying act, the infamous Donnelly family farmhouse was set ablaze, and inside, James and Johannah Donnelly, along with several of their children, were attacked in a savage mob assault that would shock Canada and echo through history.
The story of the Black Donnellys is a tale woven from family loyalty, bitter rivalries, and a tragic massacre that continues to haunt the Canadian consciousness more than 140 years later. But to truly understand this dark chapter, we have to look beyond the violent night and into the complicated lives that led up to it.
The Donnellys came to Canada in the 1840s from Tipperary, Ireland, hoping for a new life and a fresh start. James Donnelly’s daring abduction of his bride Johannah, spiriting her away from her father’s home, set a tone of conflict that seemed destined to follow the family across the ocean. Settling in Biddulph Township, they were part of a fractured Irish immigrant community, one split not just by religious lines—Protestants and Catholics—but also by deep-seated factions among Catholics themselves.
This old-world tension manifested locally in the notorious division between the so-called Blackfeet and Whiteboys, rival Catholic factions whose grudges had traveled from Ireland to Canada. The Donnellys, branded as Blackfeet, became targets of suspicion and scorn, their reputation as unruly and dangerous further cemented by ongoing disputes over land, business, and honor.
Land ownership was the battleground where much of the Donnellys’ conflict played out. Their claim to a parcel on the Roman Line—a stretch of farmland in Biddulph—was challenged repeatedly. When a court ruled to split the land with a rival family, tensions escalated, erupting into violent confrontations, including a deadly fight in which James Donnelly killed Patrick Farrell. Instead of fleeing, James hid disguised as a woman until eventually surrendering, receiving a prison sentence thanks to his wife’s tireless advocacy.
Upon his release, the Donnellys were more determined than ever to claim their place and power. They expanded into the stagecoach business, clashing violently with rivals, resulting in fires, shootings, and numerous court cases. But it was not just the law or rival families that stood against them—the local Catholic Church, led by Father John Connolly, rallied for peace through the Biddulph Peace Society, a pledge the Donnellys refused to sign. This refusal marked them as outsiders and enemies within their own community.
The tragic climax came on that bitter February night in 1880 when a mob of roughly 35 men, fueled by whiskey and hatred, stormed the Donnelly homestead. Armed with axes, clubs, and firearms, they brutally murdered James, Johannah, and three of their children, setting the house ablaze in a horrifying act of vigilante “justice.” Despite eyewitness testimony from a young boy who hid under a bed, the killers walked free after two trials that revealed a community unwilling to face the truth or punish its own.
For decades, the Donnellys’ story lived in whispered legend and local silence. The family tombstone, boldly inscribed with the word “Murdered,” became a magnet for curious visitors and vandals alike, prompting its eventual removal and replacement. Still, the legacy of the Black Donnellys refused to fade.
In the years since, their story has transcended the tragic event, becoming a symbol in Canadian folklore. Museums, theatrical productions, songs, and television shows have kept their memory alive, painting a complex portrait of a family both feared and admired. Ghost stories and local myths add an eerie layer to their legend, with tales of spectral riders and haunted fields captivating imaginations.
Today, the Lucan Area Heritage & Donnelly Museum stands as a testament to this turbulent past, offering visitors a chance to walk through history and hear the story firsthand. The Donnellys, once cast out and condemned, have become a part of the cultural fabric of Ontario—and Canada itself.
The Black Donnellys remind us that history is rarely black and white. Their tale is one of survival, conflict, and community fractures that resonate beyond their time. As you listen to this episode, we invite you to consider the complexities behind the headlines, and how a small family’s tragic fate still shapes the stories we tell about justice, loyalty, and the price of vengeance.
Listen to the full episode now on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your true crime fix. If you’re fascinated by tales of dark history and unresolved mysteries, be sure to subscribe and never miss an episode of Historical True Crime.
